Ask a question to other Boomeraters!

See other questions in the Financial & Legal forum

"Which is better? IRA vs. Roth IRA vs. investing in Gold"

  • Bev911
    Posted: Oct 12, 2009 10:49 AM
    Flag for inappropriate language
    Richmond, VA
    View Profile

    Is it true I can convert a a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA to save paying income tax on the earnings? I'm planning to retire in a few years, but with the economy the way it is should I even still contribute to my IRA? I was thinking of investing in gold - it seems safer. What is the best type of gold to buy? Where do you keep it, in a safe deposit box?


  • #1
    Posted: Oct 26, 2009 01:18 PM
    Flag for inappropriate language
    Chattanooga, TN
    View Profile

    In 2010 people with adjusted gross incomes of more than $100,000 have the opportunity to convert a traditional IRA to a Roth and spread the tax bill over two years.

    Among the many variables concerning whether a traditional or Roth is "better":

    What tax bracket are you in now versus your anticipated tax bracket at retirement?

    Can you afford to pay the tax bill on the conversion?

    What is the investment performance? (The more an investment gains after the Roth conversion, the better having already paid the tax bill on a smaller dollar amount becomes.)

    As for the investment of gold, for simplicity, I prefer gold and gold mining exchange traded funds. While owning physical gold can be very attractive, you do have to keep it in a safety deposit box. Purchasing and selling gold are fraught with difficulties, time delays, large commissions, and the opportunity to be taken advantage of by unscrupulous hucksters.

  • #2
    Ken Clamurro
    Posted: Jan 12, 2010 01:19 AM
    Flag for inappropriate language
    Ken Clamurro
    Folsom, CA
    View Profile

    Other variables would include your age, attitude toward risk, and participation in other retirement plans. Whether or not gold has already had a substantial run to the upside, you'll need to consider how it "fits" among your other personal and retirement assets, and if it reduces or increases your total asset (portfolio) risk. There are no "fules of thumb" that can be relied upon.

    A competent financial planner should be involved to discuss the risks, your investment timeline/horizon, tax situation now and in the future,and alternatives that are more likely to accomplish your own unique objectives.

  • #3
    Posted: Feb 02, 2010 04:17 PM
    Flag for inappropriate language
    New York, NY
    View Profile

    Converting from a traditional to a Roth IRA can be a great financial decision for many of us, but a word of caution before you rush into this. There are 2 key advantages to the Roth IRA: 1) you pay taxes up front so your disbursements when you retire are tax free – a key advantage if you expect your income, and therefore your tax rate, will increase, and 2) with a Roth IRA you are not required to take minimum distributions, whereas with a traditional IRA you must start distributions after age 70 ½. and pay taxes on those distributions. Plus you can spread the income tax on your conversions in 2010 over two years, paying half in 2010 and half in 2011.

    So what’s the downside? 1) Converting can bump you into a higher tax bracket, so calculate the tax you will pay to determine if the conversion is worth it 2) Don’t convert if you think your tax bracket will fall, not rise. Why pay higher taxes now than you will have to pay in the future? Two other tips: Don’t put all of your traditional IRA eggs into one existing Roth IRA basket, spreading your money is a safer bet. And, after you convert be sure to watch what’s happening. If the value of your converted Roth IRA drops significantly you can undo the conversion, reverting back to a traditional IRA. This is a key tactic you should not overlook. Unless you will very diligently keep an eye on your investments, you will be safer having your financial planner advise you.

Post your reply

Do you have some thoughts to add or some advice to give?
Only registered Boomeraters can post replies. Log in to your account or Sign up now (it's free)



Looking for a financial advisor?

Search our extensive database of over 3,500 advisors from both independent and large firms.

Enter your zipcode below

Or use this link to find a financial advisor or find a lawyer